Why Fewer First-Time Buyers Are Entering the Market in MA & NH

Once upon a time, the path to homeownership started in your late 20s. Today, the median age of a first-time buyer has climbed to 38 — the highest in U.S. history. In Massachusetts and New Hampshire, where prices remain high and incomes haven’t kept pace, first-time buyers make up only 24% of the market. This generational shift isn’t just a national trend — it’s reshaping local markets, too. Let’s explore why fewer young buyers are entering the game and what it means for buyers, sellers, and lenders alike.

The Shrinking First-Time Buyer Pool

In 2010, first-time buyers represented half the housing market. By 2024, that number dropped to less than a quarter. It’s not because younger generations don’t want to buy — surveys show they do — but the financial barriers are higher than ever.

For Massachusetts and New Hampshire buyers, the challenge is particularly acute. Both states rank among the nation’s most expensive housing markets, with limited inventory and bidding wars still common in desirable areas. That leaves many would-be buyers sidelined, even when mortgage rates dip slightly.

Why It’s Harder Than Ever

Income vs. Home Prices

The income needed to buy a median-priced home has soared to over $126,000 a year, nearly 60% higher than in 2021. Meanwhile, household incomes in the region have barely budged. That mismatch has locked many younger buyers out of the market.

Rising Debt Loads

Millennials and Gen Z carry heavy financial baggage, from student loans to credit card balances. With Gen Z’s average personal debt topping $94,000, saving for a down payment feels more like a marathon than a sprint.

Limited Starter Homes

Entry-level homes — once the natural first step into ownership — are scarce. Many builders in New England focus on higher-margin luxury units, while affordable starter homes are either aging or quickly snapped up.

Demographic Shifts

Younger generations are delaying marriage, children, and long-term settling, which historically drove first-home purchases. Add in higher rent burdens and inflation, and the dream of ownership is being pushed later into life.

What This Means for Sellers

If you’re selling in Massachusetts or New Hampshire, this trend could mean fewer young families competing for your property. That may soften demand in some price brackets, especially for entry-level homes. On the flip side, it also means that when younger buyers do show up, they’re highly motivated — and often well-prepared with family support, FHA financing, or cash gifts.

What This Means for Lenders

Lenders can’t assume yesterday’s products will work for today’s market. Winning over first-time buyers requires:

• FHA and low down payment options to lower the entry barrier
• Alternative credit scoring (including rental and utility history) to qualify more applicants
• Digital-first lending to meet younger buyers where they are
• Educational resources to guide cautious, debt-burdened buyers through the process

The lenders who succeed won’t just hand out mortgages — they’ll provide tools, trust, and guidance.

What This Means for Buyers

If you’re a first-time buyer in MA or NH, you’re not alone in feeling like the deck is stacked against you. But there are pathways forward:

• Explore FHA or MassHousing programs that reduce down payment hurdles
• Work with a closing attorney early to understand costs and risks
• Consider expanding your search beyond major metros into more affordable towns or suburbs